New York 12th

Solid D

>99 in 100

Chance the Democrat wins (>99.9%)

<1 in 100

Chance the Republican wins (<0.1%)

See the national overview

Forecasted turnout

Partisan lean

# How the forecast has changed

We'll be updating our forecasts every time new data is available, every day through Nov. 6.

Chance of winning

Popular vote share

KEY

AVERAGE

80% CHANCE OF FALLING IN RANGE

# What goes into the

classic forecast in the New York 12th

The Classic version of our model projects a race’s outcome by taking a weighted average of polls of a district (if available), polls of similar districts (CANTOR) and non-polling factors (fundamentals). It is then reverted toward a mean based on long-term trends in midterms and presidential approval ratings.

—
Adjusted polls
D+79.5
CANTOR
D+66.4
Fundamentals
D+68.2
Experts

D+79.5

Lite
D+67.8

Classic
D+67.9

Deluxe

<0.1
<0.1

Historical adjustment

Key

More weight

Less

#Latest polls

We haven’t been able to find any polls for this district. Know of one? Send us an email.

#Similar districts and CANTOR

Our district similarity scores are based on demographic, geographic and political characteristics; if two districts have a score of 100, it means they are perfectly identical. These scores inform a system we use — CANTOR, or Congressional Algorithm using Neighboring Typologies to Optimize Regression — to infer what polling would say in unpolled or lightly polled districts, given what it says in similar districts.

Districts most similar to the New York 12th

	Sim. score	Polling avg.
NY-10	68	—
MA-5	33	—
VA-8	19	—
NY-9	17	—
NY-16	17	—
IL-5	16	—
IL-9	15	—
MA-7	14	—
CA-12	14	—
WA-7	14	—

#The “fundamentals”

The Classic and Deluxe versions of our model use several non-polling factors to forecast the vote share margin in each district.

Factor	Impact	Explanation
Incumbency	2.7	Carolyn Maloney has been elected to 13 terms. Congress has only a 20.1% approval rating, reducing the incumbency advantage.
District partisanship	21.8	NY-12 is 62.6 percentage points more Democratic-leaning than the country overall, based on how it has voted in recent presidential and state legislative elections. It voted for Clinton in 2016 and Obama in 2012.
Incumbent's margin in last election	27.8	Maloney won by 66.3 percentage points in 2016.
Generic ballot	5.8	Democrats lead by an average of 8.6 percentage points in polls of the generic congressional ballot.
Fundraising	10.4	As of Oct. 17, Maloney had raised $1,142,000 in individual contributions (99% of all such contributions to the major-party candidates); Eliot Rabin had raised $11,000 (1%).
Incumbent's voting record in Congress	2.7	Maloney has voted with Democrats 92% of the time in roll-call votes in recent sessions of Congress. Candidates who vote with their party very frequently tend to underperform at the ballot booth, other factors held equal.
Challenger experience	0.6	Rabin has never held elected office.
Scandals	0.0	Neither candidate is involved in a scandal.
Total	D+66.4

#Expert ratings

The Deluxe version of our model calculates an implied margin for each race based on expert race ratings from The Cook Political Report, Inside Elections and Sabato's Crystal Ball; it then adjusts that margin toward its estimate of the national political environment.

		Equivalent Margin
Expert	Rating	Raw	Adjusted
Cook Political Report	Solid D	D+67.8	D+68.4
Inside Elections	Solid D	D+67.8	D+68.7
Sabato's Crystal Ball	Safe D	D+67.8	D+67.4
Average		D+67.8	D+68.2

How this forecast works

Nate Silver explains the methodology behind our 2018 midterms forecast. Read more …

Search for a race or candidate